Skip to content
New Fate Cakes Logo
  • Desserts
    • Pickup
    • Delivery (DoorDash)
  • Cakes
    • Pricing
    • Order
      • Quick Cakes
      • Custom (Pre-Order)
    • Schedule A Tasting
  • Events
    • Weddings
    • Birthdays
    • Baby Showers
    • Wedding Showers
    • Graduations
    • Special Occasions
  • Gallery
  • About
    • Location / Delivery
    • Contact
  • 614.219.9429
  • Desserts
    • Pickup
    • Delivery (DoorDash)
  • Cakes
    • Pricing
    • Order
      • Quick Cakes
      • Custom (Pre-Order)
    • Schedule A Tasting
  • Events
    • Weddings
    • Birthdays
    • Baby Showers
    • Wedding Showers
    • Graduations
    • Special Occasions
  • Gallery
  • About
    • Location / Delivery
    • Contact
  • 614.219.9429
$0.00 0 Cart
Home / Products

Showing 1–12 of 60 results

  • Cake Tasting Boxes are available for preorder

    Cake Tasting Box

    $15.00     Add to cart
  • Chocolate Chip Sammy Cookie Sandwich

    Chocolate Chip Sammy (1ct)

    $5.00     Add to cart
  • Gluten Free buckeye candy

    JUMBO Buckeye (Gluten Free) (1ct)

    $3.00     Add to cart
  • Jumbo Chocolate Chip Cookie

    JUMBO Chocolate Chip (1ct)

    $3.50     Add to cart
  • Jumbo M&M Cookie

    JUMBO M&M Cookie (1ct)

    $3.50     Add to cart
  • Oatmeal Cookie sandwich with icing in the middle

    Jumbo Oatmeal Cream Pie (1ct)

    $4.75     Add to cart
  • A JUMBO rice treat

    JUMBO Rice Treat (Gluten Free) (1ct) (Designs Vary)

    $4.00     Add to cart
  • Vanilla cake with sprinkles and vanilla colored icing

    Funfetti (Colors May Vary)

    $3.00     Add to cart
  • Choose up to 4 flavors to mix and match your dozen cupcakes

    Custom Assortment (Dozen)

    $36.00     Select options
  • Anniversary White pearl cake

    Anniversary Cakes

    Read more
  • Baby Shower Tiered Giraffe Themed Cake

    Baby Shower Cakes

    Read more
  • Tiered Birthday Cake for 1st birthday

    Birthday Cakes

    Read more
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • →

Getting Married? CLICK HERE to schedule a cake tasting box!

Fate Cakes
614.219.9429
1360 Cherry Bottom Road
Wed: 9AM-2PM
Thur/Fri: 9AM-5PM
Sat: 9AM-2PM
Sun-Tues: CLOSED

Order Online

  • Delivery - DoorDash
  • Pickup
  • Schedule A Cake Tasting
  • My Cart
  • Checkout

Events

  • Weddings
  • Birthdays
  • Baby Showers
  • Bridal Showers
  • Graduations

Bakery

  • Contact
  • About
  • Location
  • Gallery
  • License / Copyright

Connect

  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • TikTok
  • Venmo
X

    Contact Our Bakery