Custom Sheet Cakes

Sheet cakes are easy to serve at parties with a large amount of guest, but we customize ours with special themed designs. We’re always looking for new inventive designs and our bakers enjoy decorating a custom cake – we love a challenge!

Give us a ring (614) 219.9429 to order your custom sheet cakes cake over the phone and to ask any additional questions about our Cake Services; as well as, our Cake Pricing

Description

Order Information: Please contact our design team to discuss accurate pricing on all custom cakes. To the left is a list of our standard single and two-tiered pricing. Additional customization to your order may increase the total price.

3.5 (70%) 16 votes

Vanilla Brown Butter

Vanilla cake base with brown butter icing as filling, traditional vanilla icing covering.

Double Chocolate Mud

Chocolate cake base with chocolate filling and chocolate icing.

Cookie Crunch

Vanilla & crushed cookie cake base; filling is a line of chocolate with crushed/filling and vanilla icing, topped with a crushed cookie icing.

Red Velvet

Red velvet cake base with cream cheese icing as filling and surrounding.

Strawberry Cheesecake

Strawberry cake base with a strawberry filling and cheesecake icing and strawberry swirl.

Victorian Almond

Almond cake base with raspberry filling covered with our traditional vanilla icing and shaved Almonds.

Buckeye

Chocolate cake base, peanut butter icing, chopped buckeye pieces with icing in filling and decorated with mini buckeyes.

Lemon Poppy

Lemon Poppy seed cake base; lemon center filling, lemon icing

Coconut Dream

Coconut cake base, with coconut cream cheese frosting, decorated with toasted coconut.

Gluten Free White Raspberry

Gluten free vanilla cake base with a raspberry filling, and traditional vanilla icing covering. *Additional Pricing Applies*

Gluten Free Black Forest

Gluten free chocolate cake, cherry filling, vanilla buttercream icing. *Additional Pricing Applies*
3.5 (70%) 16 votes

FREE Local Columbus, Ohio delivery.

The below listing shows all base pricing. Additional costs may apply to custom designs; as well as, non Columbus, Ohio ZIP codes.

Circle Cake Size Party Servings (2″ x 4″) Buttercream Fondant
6″ Circle 10 $45.00 $55.00
8″ Circle 16 $55.00 $79.00
9″ Circle 20 $65.00 $95.00
10″ Circle 26 $80.00 $119.00
12” Circle 36 $115.00 $159.00
14” Circle 52 $145.00 $223.00
16” Circle 60 $165.00 $265.00

 

Circle Cake Size Wedding Servings (1″ x 4″) Buttercream Fondant
6″ Circle 12 $65.00 $80.00
8″ Circle 28 $85.00 $137.00
9″ Circle 33 $97.50 $147.00
10″ Circle 42 $135.00 $183.00
12” Circle 56 $155.00 $237.00
14” Circle 82 $220.00 $343.00
16” Circle 100 $265.00 $415.00

 

Square Cake Size Party Servings (2″ x 4″) Buttercream Fondant
6″ Square 12 $55.00 $60.00
8″ Square 20 $65.00 $95.00
10″ Square 30 $90.00 $135.00
12” Square 40 $115.00 $175.00
14” Square 56 $165.00 $239.00
16” Square 80 $215.00 $335.00

 

Square Cake Size Wedding Servings (1″ x 4″) Buttercream Fondant
6″ Square 18 $80.00 $95.00
8″ Square 32 $95.00 $143.00
10″ Square 50 $140.00 $215.00
12” Square 72 $195.00 $303.00
14” Square 98 $260.00 $405.00
16” Square 128 $335.00 $527.00
3.5 (70%) 16 votes

FREE Local Columbus, Ohio delivery.

The below listing shows all base pricing.  Additional costs may apply to custom designs; as well as, non Columbus, Ohio ZIP codes.

Circle Cake Size Party Servings (2″ x 4″) Buttercream
Fondant
6″ / 9″ Circle 30 $127.00 $157.00
8″ / 10″ Circle 42 $163.00 $205.00
9″ / 12″ Circle 56 $205.00 $261.00
10″ / 14″ Circle 78 $271.00 $349.00
12” / 16″ Circle 96 $325.00 $421.00

 

Circle Cake Size Wedding Servings (1″ x 4″) Buttercream
Fondant
6″ / 9″ / 12″ Circle 100 $337.00 $437.00
8″ / 9″ / 10″ Circle 130 $427.00 $557.00
6″ / 10″/ 14″ Circle 150 $487.00 $637.00
8″ / 12″ / 16″ Circle 185 $592.00 $777.00
12″ / 14″ / 16″ Circle 240 $757.00 $997.00
8″ / 10″ / 12″ / 14″ Circle 235 $742.00 $977.00
8″ / 12″ / 14″ / 16” Circle 265 $835.00 $1,097.00

 

Square Cake Size Party Servings (2″ x 4″) Buttercream Fondant
6″ / 8″ Square 32 $133.00 $165.00
8″ / 10″ Square 50 $187.00 $237.00
10″ / 12″ Square 70 $247.00 $307.00
12″ / 14″ Square 96 $325.00 $421.00

 

Square Cake Size Wedding Servings (1″ x 4″) Buttercream
Fondant
6″ / 8″ / 10″ Square 95 $322.00 $512.00
6″ / 10″ / 14″ Square 160 $517.00 $677.00
8″ / 12″ / 16″ Square 225 $712.00 $903.00
8″ / 10″ / 12″ / 14″ Square 250 $787.00 $1,037.00
8″ / 12″ / 14″ / 16” Square 318 $991.00 $1,309.00
3.5 (70%) 16 votes

During checkout you will be asked to include the delivery location; as well as, delivery date of your order. If you are ordering your item to be delivered to a different location please select “Deliver To Different Address” during the checkout process. You will also have the opportunity to add a personal message to any order before finalizing the checkout.

All payment is made through PayPal but you do not need a PayPal account to process any transactions. On redirection to PayPal while submitting your order you will have the option to either pay with a PayPal account or any major Credit Card or Debit Cards (Visa / Mastercard / American Express / Discover).

Don’t want to submit an order online? Give us a call and we will discuss you order over the phone (614.219.9429)

3.5 (70%) 16 votes

We offer delivery of all our lil’ treats to any location within the Columbus, Ohio area including Gahanna, Ohio and other areas in Central Ohio. Please Click Here to read more about our delivery terms and conditions; as well as, additional locations within Columbus, Ohio in which we will deliver.

3.5 (70%) 16 votes

Hosting a party within Columbus, Ohio or a surrounding area? Fate Cakes’ offers endless catering services. Having a Wedding, Bridal Shower, Baby Shower and Graduation or just getting together for a birthday? Give us a call (614) 219.9429 and we’ll handle all the details while you sit back and enjoy some sweet treats!

3.5 (70%) 16 votes