Custom Cookies

We have dozens of cookie cutters in our bakery just waiting to be stamp out your next custom cookie order. Our soft sugar cookies are the perfect canvas to paint a work of art for your next themed event and we’ll decorate any cookie to the design of your choice. From large weddings to a more intimate birthday party, these little treats are sure to be a crowd pleaser.

Give us a ring (614) 219.9429 to order your custom cookies over the phone and to ask any additional questions about our Cookie Services; as well as, our Cookie Pricing


Please contact our design team to discuss accurate pricing on all custom cookies. All our custom cookie designs start at a flat price/each and additional customizations to your order may increase the total price. (NOTE: All our cookies use variations of Royal Icing as decorations).

3.7 (73.33%) 3 votes

All of our cookies start at $3.00/each and are around 3 – 3 1/2″ in diameter


Additional Pricing:

Popsicle Stick = $.50/each

Cellophane Wrapper w/Ribbon (Matching theme) = $1.00/each

Message/Monogram = $.50/each

3.7 (73.33%) 3 votes

When ordering from our custom cookie menu, there is a minimum order of 2 Dozen (24 cookies) and you have the option of up to 4 custom cookie designs. We absolutely understand most parties call for more than 4 designs, but because each cookie needs some extra TLC there will be an additional fee applied to all additional designs and will be priced out accordingly to the difficulty of the design

3.7 (73.33%) 3 votes

During checkout you will be asked to include the delivery location; as well as, delivery date of your order. If you are ordering your item to be delivered to a different location please select “Deliver To Different Address” during the checkout process. You will also have the opportunity to add a personal message to any order before finalizing the checkout.

All payment is made through PayPal but you do not need a PayPal account to process any transactions. On redirection to PayPal while submitting your order you will have the option to either pay with a PayPal account or any major Credit Card or Debit Cards (Visa / Mastercard / American Express / Discover).

Don’t want to submit an order online? Give us a call and we will discuss you order over the phone (614.219.9429)

3.7 (73.33%) 3 votes

We offer delivery of all our lil’ treats to any location within the Columbus, Ohio area including Hilliard, Ohio and other areas in Central Ohio. Please Click Here to read more about our delivery terms and conditions; as well as, additional locations within Columbus, Ohio in which we will deliver.

3.7 (73.33%) 3 votes

Hosting a party within Columbus, Ohio or a surrounding area? Fate Cakes’ offers endless catering services. Having a Wedding, Bridal Shower, Baby Shower and Graduation or just getting together for a birthday? Give us a call (614) 219.9429 and we’ll handle all the details while you sit back and enjoy some sweet treats!

3.7 (73.33%) 3 votes